Governator II: The revenge of the boxes
December 2nd, 2008, 6:30 am · 14 Comments · posted by Teri Sforza, Register staff writer
California is going broke, the governor said as he declared a fiscal emergency on Monday, calling lawmakers into a special session to grapple anew with an $11.2 billion deficit.
Which got The Watchdog to thinking about the Good Old Days. “Every governor proposes moving boxes around to reorganize government,” Arnold Schwarzenegger said in his “State of the State” address in January 2004. “I don’t want to move boxes around; I want to blow them up.”
Boom! ”We have multiple departments with overlapping responsibilities. I say consolidate them.”
Boom! “We have boards and commissions that serve no pressing public need. I say abolish them.”
Boom! “I plan a total review of government - its performance, its practices, its cost.”
Boom, indeed. The fruit of these explosions was delivered in 2005 - in the California Performance Review, a blow-up-the-boxes-blueprint for government reform detailing some $32 billion in savings. (Doesn’t that sound good right about now?) It scrutinized more than 300 state boards and commissions and recommended axing 88 of them.
Yet nearly four years - and many crippling budget crises - later, there’s little to show for it. “Not only did these recommendations fall on deaf ears,” outgoing state Rep. Todd Spitzer recently told The Watchdog, “but since this report was released, state government has dramatically grown. In fact, since the Governor took office, the state has added nearly 700,000 jobs.”
Our great state’s black hole is expected to hit $28 billion over the next year-and-a-half unless something is done. Schwarzenegger’s emergency declaration authorizes the governor and lawmakers to change the existing budget within the next 45 days. Without quick action, the state might run out of cash in February.
Ak. Whither the California Performance Review and its $32 billion savings?!
It’s not exactly that the Governator didn’t try. (Our colleague John Gittelsohn catalogued the incredible quagmire attendant to such reform attempts in “Part-time work, full-time pay.”) Yet when The Watchdog asked the governor’s office about what the heck happened to the California Performance Review - asking, specifically, “Does it seem like, rather than blowing up the boxes, the boxes blew up him?” - Schwarzenegger spokesman Aaron McLear said, “I don’t understand the question.”
The governor, McLear said, ”has been reforming since the minute he got into office.” He offered examples:
- A revamped workers compensation system that’s easier on employers.
- Budget reform that would create a rainy-day fund for California (which will appear on next year’s ballot).
- Redistricting reform (the just-passed Proposition 11), which may elect more centrist and responsive leaders.
- A revamped Department of Motor Vehicles, where many services have gone online and wait times have dropped.
- A streamlined juvenile corrections department was merged into the larger department of corrections.
- Marrying the state’s emergency services department with its homeland security department.
“The governor totally agrees that we need to constantly look for waste, fraud and abuse in state government and root that out,” McLear said. “But some are suggesting that if we get rid of waste, fraud and abuse, that could solve our budget shortfall. That’s just not the case.”
He even emailed The Watchdog a quote from nonpartisan Legislative Analyst Mac Taylor, backing that up.
The Governator, of course, thinks that the fairest way to plug the hole is through budget cuts and tax hikes (raising the sales tax to 8.75 percent - from 7.25 percent - for three years; raising motor vehicle fees, etc.).
Democrats are with him, but Republicans will ice skate in hell before budging from their no-new-taxes stance.
We the People are getting very tired of this nonsense.
There is a structural problem in the state budget. Fix it.
We spend more than we take in. Stop it.
And there is a rather exhaustive 2,500 page blueprint of ideas - put together by 275 people - on how to make California government more efficient. For goodness sake! Use it!
(An aside on that awesome picture of Schwarzenegger and the cat: Found it here, under the heading “An unreleased scene from the movie Commando.”)
More Watchdog:
- After priest scandal, Catholic Diocese’s financial rebound is heavenly
- Hoag, CHOC hospital execs earn more than $1 million each
- OC charity for burn victims burns donors
- OC Scouts leader’s pay rose while revenue fell
- AIG junket - the movie! Bailed-out execs luxuriate on tape
- AIG subsidiary parties in style in OC, two weeks after bailout
- Yet another AIG subsidiary parties hearty days after bailout
- High-flying AIG subsidiary gets to play with Uncle Sam’s dough, too
- Truth or dare? AIG ordered to bare all its secrets
- Should feds have let AIG go bankrupt?
- Bailed-out banks ordered to reveal executive compensation
- AIG suspends controversial executive payouts worth millions
- God’s quid pro quo?
- Earthly kingdom: Trinity’s $167 million in real estate
- Crusading for ‘Judeo-Christian values’ doesn’t come cheap
- OC Scouts leader’s pay rose while revenue fell












December 2nd, 2008 at 11:12 am
I just saw a article in the LA Times bemoaning the situation that newly elected representatives will have a hard time finding funding for their new programs ideas. We are in a terminal financial crisis and the LA Times wants new government programs to spend even more tax money. The LA Times is defunct.
December 2nd, 2008 at 12:58 pm
Terri:
If the State had 700,000 employees we would be in a much bigger deficit than 28 Billion. You might make more sense if you are conveniently ignoring the attrition rate.
December 2nd, 2008 at 1:10 pm
Arnold Schwarzenegger has always been 100% Democrat His over spending, his wife, his love of the illegals, his no on eight, He has helped to drive companies and good workers out of California. He is not competent enough to be the shovel man behind the circus elephants.
December 2nd, 2008 at 1:20 pm
who cares if the state is making money or losing money. we aren’t going to see any more or less of it either way…
December 2nd, 2008 at 1:43 pm
One word….ILLEGALS.
That’s a pretty good example of abuse. Abuse of the hard-working, legal citizens of this state.
December 2nd, 2008 at 1:46 pm
meh
December 2nd, 2008 at 2:11 pm
The one thing that is needed to fix the financial problem in California is the one thing the state is incapable of doing. That is cutting spending.
December 2nd, 2008 at 2:32 pm
wHAT’S UP WITH THAT CAT & ARNOLD PICTURE? IT LOOKS HELLA FUNNY BUT WHAT’S IT SUPPOSED TO MEAN? ( THE CAT’S OUTA THE BAG )
December 2nd, 2008 at 2:51 pm
Sean - an element of herding cats, perhaps?!
December 2nd, 2008 at 2:58 pm
Does any one know the total State employee count? 700,000 new employees? It seems as if this is either an exaggeration, or a mistake. Either way, let’s put this thing into perspective. We knew this was coming, and the State elected officials let it happen. You can’t continually increase spending because you have short term increases in revenue. Our state legislators are incompetent, and there’s no nicer way to put it.
December 2nd, 2008 at 3:13 pm
Last night, I saw an anti-tobacco ad on during prime time. It was sponsored by the state.
Nice use of money we don’t have!!
December 2nd, 2008 at 3:47 pm
the liberal hack is trying to get re-elected. that’s why he is being a girly-man
December 3rd, 2008 at 2:00 am
California has 141,000 employees…..including retirees
December 3rd, 2008 at 2:03 am
from above post see,,,,,,,, http://www.calcsea.org